Coral Gables was designed to look a certain way. George Merrick's plan in the 1920s, and the city's incorporation in 1925, produced streets of Mediterranean Revival homes with stucco walls, barrel-tile roofs, arched openings, and courtyards, anchored by landmarks such as the Biltmore Hotel and the Venetian Pool. A century later, people who buy these homes usually love that character and want to protect it, while still having a kitchen and bathrooms that work for modern life.
Tile sits right at that intersection. Choose well and the house feels both original and refreshed. Choose poorly and a renovated room can look like it belongs in a different building. Here is how to approach it.
Start with what the house is telling you
Look at the fixed elements you're keeping: wood ceiling beams, wrought iron, plaster arches, original fireplaces, old pecky cypress. Those set the palette. Mediterranean homes usually look best with warm, earthy tones such as cream, sand, honey, soft terracotta, and aged stone, rather than icy whites or high-contrast black-and-white schemes.
Porcelain is useful here because it reproduces travertine, limestone, and terracotta looks convincingly, without the sealing and staining issues of the natural materials.
Respect proportion
Many historic rooms are generous but broken up by arches and alcoves. A very large tile can look elegant, but in a room with lots of angles it may produce many awkward cuts. A medium-to-large format laid in a simple pattern often feels more natural. In hallways and loggias, a classic pattern, such as an offset or a versailles-style layout, can echo the period.
Ask us to lay out a few pieces in the showroom so you can judge scale before you commit.
Kitchens: modern function, old-world look
Kitchens are where most Coral Gables owners want the biggest update. A marble-look porcelain backsplash and a warm stone-look floor let you install modern cabinets and appliances while keeping the mood of the house. Porcelain shrugs off cooking spills, citrus, and wine in a way that real marble and limestone don't.
Bathrooms: classic marble without the upkeep
Statuario and Calacatta-style porcelain fit naturally in a historic bathroom, especially paired with traditional fixtures. Because porcelain is dense with very low water absorption, showers don't need regular sealing. If your home still has an original decorative tile bath you love, consider keeping it and updating only the floor or shower.
Something truly specific? Have it made
Sometimes nothing in stock matches the image in your head: a particular border, a color taken from an original tile, or a pattern for a foyer. Benigni Tiles can manufacture custom designs to order. Bring a photo or a sample and we'll talk through what is possible and the lead time involved.
Know the rules for exterior work
Coral Gables takes historic preservation seriously. Many properties are designated or within historic districts, and exterior changes may require review. Interior tile is generally not the focus, but terraces, entry steps, courtyards, and pool areas can be. Check with the City of Coral Gables before finalizing outdoor plans, and choose an exterior-rated porcelain with suitable slip resistance for anything outside.
Lighting changes everything
Coral Gables homes often have deep overhangs, loggias, and shaded windows that keep rooms cool but filter the light. A tile that looks perfect under bright showroom lights can read darker or greyer at home. Always take a sample and look at it in the actual room at different times of day: morning, late afternoon, and under your evening lighting. Warm white or soft beige tones tend to stay inviting in shaded rooms, while cooler greys can feel flat.
Finish matters too. A honed or matte surface looks closer to aged stone and hides footprints, while a polished finish bounces more light but shows more. Many owners use matte on floors and a softer sheen on walls.
Old floors: keep, cover, or replace?
Some Gables homes still have original hardwood, Cuban tile, or terrazzo. If it can be restored, it may be worth keeping in a room or two. Where it can't, your installer will advise whether new porcelain can go over it or whether it should come up first. We supply tile, not installation, but we're happy to share product and quantity advice with your contractor.
Pools in established gardens
A traditional in-ground pool can mean removing trees and disturbing a mature landscape. Our prefabricated above-ground pools arrive finished and are installed in days with no excavation on a level site. As with any exterior project in the city, confirm local requirements first.
See it at full size
Our showroom is at 10605 SW 186th St, a drive south down US-1. We're open Monday to Friday 8:30 AM–5:00 PM and Saturday 8:30 AM–4:00 PM; call (305) 646-1377 or contact us so we can have samples ready. Learn more on our Coral Gables porcelain tile page.